Year-End Payroll Checklist for Security Firms

Year-end payroll is one of the most demanding administrative periods for security companies. Between round-the-clock shifts, fluctuating overtime, multiple pay rates, and strict compliance requirements, even small errors can create major issues. Missed deadlines, incorrect tax filings, or inaccurate PTO balances do not just affect your bottom line. They impact guard trust, operational continuity, and regulatory standing.

A well-structured year-end payroll checklist gives payroll administrators and operations leaders a clear path to closing the year accurately and confidently. This guide walks through each essential step while showing how automation, especially through Belfry, reduces errors, improves accountability, and makes year-end reporting far more manageable.

Why Year-End Payroll Is High-Risk for Security Companies

Security payroll is different from traditional payroll. Guards often work overnight shifts that span pay periods, cover emergency assignments, and earn variable overtime. PTO policies vary by state, and ACA eligibility depends on monthly hours worked.

Without a centralized system, manual payroll management creates several risks:

• Inaccurate overtime calculations due to missed punches
• Misclassified guards triggering tax and labor penalties
• PTO balance disputes at year-end
• Incomplete documentation for audits or ACA reporting

This is why payroll compliance for security companies depends heavily on accurate timekeeping, scheduling, and documentation, not just filing forms on time.

Step 1: Verify Employee and Contractor Classification (W-2 vs 1099)

One of the most important year-end reviews is confirming worker classification. The distinction between employees and contractors has serious tax and labor implications.

Understanding W-2 vs. 1099 security guards is critical. In most cases, guards qualify as W-2 employees because the company controls their schedules, assignments, uniforms, training, and reporting requirements. Independent contractor classifications are rare in this industry and heavily scrutinized.

Before filing year-end forms, confirm that:

• Each guard is classified consistently across payroll, scheduling, and tax records
• Contractor payments meet IRS and state guidelines
• Any classification changes during the year are documented properly

Legal disclaimer: Worker classification rules are governed by the IRS and state labor agencies. This content is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Using security guard payroll software helps enforce consistent classifications by linking worker status directly to pay rules, timekeeping, and reporting.

Step 2: Reconcile Timekeeping, Attendance, and Overtime

Accurate time data is the foundation of compliant payroll. Before closing the year, payroll teams should reconcile scheduled shifts against actual hours worked.

This review should focus on:

• Missed or late punches
• Overnight and extended shifts
• Manual time adjustments
• Overtime thresholds and rate calculations

Security companies often underestimate how quickly small timekeeping errors compound. One missed punch can affect annual overtime totals, taxable wages, and ACA eligibility.

Automated timekeeping dramatically reduces these risks by validating hours in real time and applying overtime rules consistently across all sites.

Step 3: Review PTO, Sick Leave, and Payout Requirements

Year-end is also the time to confirm paid time off and sick leave balances for every guard. Payroll and HR teams should ensure that accruals, usage, and remaining balances are accurate and aligned with company policy.

Special attention should be given to your PTO payout policy, as requirements vary by state. Some states mandate payout of unused PTO, while others allow forfeiture if policies are clearly documented and communicated.

Key checks include:

• Verifying PTO balances match timekeeping records
• Confirming payout rules by jurisdiction
• Ensuring policies are applied consistently

Legal disclaimer: PTO payout and sick leave laws vary by state and local jurisdiction. Consult legal counsel to confirm compliance.

Digital PTO tracking eliminates manual calculations and provides clear records in case of disputes or audits.

Step 4: Prepare W-2 and 1099 Forms

Once wages and time data are finalized, payroll teams can prepare W-2 and 1099 forms. Accuracy is critical, as corrections after filing create delays and compliance exposure.

Security firms should carefully review:

• Taxable wages, overtime, and bonuses
• Year-end adjustments or retroactive pay
• Contractor totals for 1099 reporting

Having all payroll data in one system simplifies form preparation and reduces the risk of mismatched totals.

Step 5: Complete ACA Reporting Requirements

For qualifying employers, ACA year-end tasks add another layer of complexity. ACA eligibility is determined monthly based on hours worked, something security companies must track carefully due to variable schedules.

Accurate ACA reporting depends on:

• Consistent monthly hour tracking
• Clear records of coverage offer
• Reliable full-time status calculations

When timekeeping, scheduling, and payroll data are disconnected, ACA reporting becomes error-prone. Integrated systems make this process far more manageable.

Step 6: Conduct a Year-End Payroll Audit

Before finalizing filings, conducting a payroll audit helps catch errors early. This step is critical for payroll management for security firms, where pay rules can vary by site, contract, or guard classification.

An effective audit reviews:

• Overtime calculations and rate changes
• PTO balances and payouts
• Alignment between scheduled and paid hours

Identifying inconsistencies before submission protects both the company and its workforce.

Step 7: Organize Records and Prepare for the New Year

Year-end payroll doesn’t stop at filing forms. Security companies should also organize payroll records and prepare for a clean start in January.

This includes:

• Archiving timecards, pay stubs, and tax forms
• Updating pay rates and PTO policies
• Reviewing overtime and scheduling rules

Strong record organization ensures audit readiness and smoother payroll operations in the new year.

How Belfry Simplifies Year-End Payroll for Security Companies

Manual payroll systems struggle to keep up with the realities of guard-based operations. Belfry was designed specifically for security teams.

Belfry automates timekeeping, attendance, PTO tracking, and overtime calculations while maintaining a clear audit trail. Payroll teams gain real-time visibility into guard activity and can generate year-end reports with confidence.

As a modern security company's payroll software, Belfry supports accurate security guard payroll, simplifies compliance documentation, and reduces administrative workload during the busiest time of the year.

Close the Year Confidently and Start the Next One Strong

A well-executed year-end payroll checklist is essential for protecting your business, supporting your guards, and maintaining compliance. For security companies, success depends on accurate data, consistent processes, and technology built for 24/7 operations.

Book a demo of Belfry today and see how year-end payroll becomes simpler, faster, and far less stressful.

Download Checklist